The thesis A society at the peak of its liberalization is not a society without a hierarchy. It is a society that has learned to grant exemptions without disturbing the order. This is the difference between a norm upgrade and a norm reordering. An upgrade adds a group to the existing arrangement. A reordering changes…
The claim The claim is narrow and it should be stated precisely, because the loose version of it is indefensible and the precise version is not. An eighteen-year-old woman is the best available judge of whether an older partner is fit. Not the best judge of his finances, his politics, or his character in every…
The label is the problem There is a status penalty attached to a particular kind of relationship, and it is not the age gap or the class gap that produces it. It is the legibility of the transfer. A man who supports a woman he is dating, directly and visibly—apartment, car, wardrobe, holidays, monthly allowance—has…
Every man carries a version of himself he has never shown anyone. Not because he is ashamed of it, necessarily, but because showing it would cost him something—status, membership, a marriage, a job, the respect of people whose respect he has spent decades earning. Then one day the cost disappears. The kids move out. The…