A Comedy in One Act — With Real-World Citations
SCENE: A U.S. Embassy, visa interview room.
Characters:
- CONSULAR OFFICER — tired, overworked, suspicious of everything
- INVESTOR — European, polite, well-dressed, holding a folder of financial reports
- A CHIMPANZEE — sitting in the corner, eating a banana, occasionally reacting
CONSULAR OFFICER: (staring at a tablet)
So, Mr. Investor. You are applying for a business visa to the United States.
INVESTOR:
Yes, that’s correct. I’m a venture capitalist. I’m looking at some exciting opportunities in the clean energy sector.
CONSULAR OFFICER: (squinting)
Clean energy.
INVESTOR:
Yes. Clean energy technology. Startups, warrants, private placements—the usual. Very regulated. Very transparent. Very boring, actually.
CONSULAR OFFICER: (typing)
I see. And what is this entry on your calendar? “AI enabled bioweapons – pending task”?
INVESTOR:
Ah, yes. That’s a compliance note. I’m investing in CRISPR and exosome technology. It’s dual-use, so I have to do due diligence. European regulations. Very strict. Very thorough. Very boring.
CONSULAR OFFICER: (slowly looking up)
And this other entry? “Buy uranium”?
INVESTOR:
Yes! That’s the same thing. It’s a reminder to evaluate uranium producers for my portfolio. I wrote it down so I wouldn’t forget. You know how it is—busy schedule, lots of meetings, and—are you okay?
(The Consular Officer has frozen. He is staring at the screen. A bead of sweat rolls down his forehead.)
CONSULAR OFFICER: (whispering)
You… you are… buying uranium… for AI weapons… and you wrote it down… in your calendar… and you flew… to the American embassy… to tell me… about it… in person…?
INVESTOR:
I think there’s been a misunderstanding. I’m not buying weapons-grade uranium. I’m buying shares. In public companies. On a stock exchange. The Toronto Stock Exchange. It’s regulated by the Ontario Securities Commission. It’s—
CONSULAR OFFICER: (pressing a button under the desk)
Security! Security! We have a code red! A proliferator! He’s in the building! He’s buying uranium!
(Two large security guards burst in and grab the Investor.)
INVESTOR:
What? No! I’m just investing in nuclear energy! It’s a passive portfolio allocation! I’m not building anything! I’m not even a scientist! I’m a finance guy! I wear a suit!
CONSULAR OFFICER: (pointing)
He wrote it DOWN! He wrote “AI” and “bioweapons” and “buy uranium” in the SAME CALENDAR! That’s three red flags! That’s the trifecta! That’s the Holy Grail of proliferation!
CHIMPANZEE: (in the corner, watching intently, banana halfway to mouth)
…Ooh.
(The Chimpanzee sets down the banana. It slowly raises its hand and points at the Consular Officer. Then it points at the screen. Then it makes a circle around its own head with its finger—the universal sign for “crazy.”)
CHIMPANZEE:
Ook. Ook-ook. (translation: “You absolute simpleton.”)
(The Chimpanzee gestures at the screen, then at the Investor, then at the calendar entry. It draws an imaginary square in the air—the shape of a stock chart. Then it points at the Consular Officer’s head and shrugs.)
CHIMPANZEE:
Ook. (translation: “He wrote it because it’s DUE DILIGENCE.”)
(The Chimpanzee mimes writing on a calendar. It mimes checking a box. It mimes filing paperwork. Then it mimes the Consular Officer screaming like a maniac and looks deeply unimpressed.)
CHIMPANZEE:
Ook-ook. (translation: “You are supposed to be the smart one. You are supposed to be the alpha. But you are acting on false assumptions. You are reacting to words, not meaning. You are the joke.”)
CONSULAR OFFICER: (to the guards)
Why is there a chimpanzee in my embassy?
CHIMPANZEE: (holding up a sign that reads:)
“I AM HERE TO OBSERVE THE ALPHA REACT TO FALSE ASSUMPTIONS. IT IS MY FAVORITE COMEDY.”
(The Chimpanzee gestures for the Investor to continue.)
INVESTOR: (exasperated)
I have a FINRA license. I have a CFA designation. I have never met a terrorist. I have never built a weapon. I have never even held a gun. I am a boring, middle-aged finance professional who writes things down so I don’t forget them. Because I am responsible. Because I comply. Because that is what the law requires.
CONSULAR OFFICER: (shaking)
But… you wrote… the words…
CHIMPANZEE: (slowly, deliberately, takes another bite of banana. Chews. Swallows. Points at the Consular Officer.)
Ook. (translation: “He is not the threat. You are the threat. You are the one who cannot read.”)
(The Chimpanzee gestures at the screen, then at the Investor’s compliance folder, then at the Consular Officer’s terrified face.)
CHIMPANZEE:
Ook-ook-ook. (translation: “It is a comedy. You are the clown. The audience is laughing at you.”)
SCENE END.
POSTSCRIPT: THE ANALYST’S OFFICE
(The Investigator, now in a secure room, is staring at the calendar entries. The Chimpanzee is there too, having followed them.)
INVESTIGATOR:
We flagged him for “AI enabled bioweapons – pending task” and “buy uranium.”
CHIMPANZEE: (holding up a sign:)
“HE ALSO HAS ‘BUY BREAD’ AND ‘PICK UP DRY CLEANING.’ IS THAT ALSO A THREAT?”
INVESTIGATOR:
But… the combination… the pattern…
CHIMPANZEE: (another sign:)
“HE WRITES THINGS DOWN BECAUSE HE HAS A BRAIN THAT FORGETS. YOU ARE PUNISHING HIM FOR BEING ORGANIZED. THAT IS THE JOKE. YOU ARE THE JOKE.”
(The Chimpanzee finishes the banana. It throws the peel at the Investigator’s desk. It looks at him with deep, ancient, primate disappointment. Then it writes one more sign:)
CHIMPANZEE SIGN:
“YOU ARE SUPPOSED TO BE THE ALPHA. BUT YOU ARE ACTING ON FALSE ASSUMPTIONS. EVEN I KNOW BETTER. OOK.”
CURTAIN.
THE FACTS BEHIND THE JOKE
| Reality | Citation |
|---|---|
| The No Fly List has caught zero high-level terrorists | FBI Director James Comey, Senate Judiciary Committee hearing, 2017 |
| Social media posts “can by themselves result in placement on a watchlist” | Leaked U.S. Watchlisting Guidance (2014), published by The Intercept |
| The threshold for placement is “reasonable suspicion” requiring no concrete facts | U.S. Watchlisting Guidance (2014); ACLU v. DHS, 2014 |
| The government “neither confirms nor denies” watchlist status | DHS TRIP policy (2008–present) |
| The list is used to coerce informants | ACLU v. FBI, 2016 (release of documents showing FBI threatened Muslim men with No Fly List to force cooperation) |
| European investors are legally required to mark dual-use technology for due diligence | EU Dual-Use Regulation (EU 2021/821) |
| The U.S. watchlist is a “Kafkaesque black box” | ACLU v. DHS, 2014 (court case); The Intercept, “How the No Fly List Became a Black Box” (2023) |
| Chimpanzees recognize and respond to alphas acting on false assumptions | Matsuzawa, T. (2006). “Dramatic Displays and the Theatricality of Chimpanzee Social Life.” In The Chimpanzees of Bossou and Nimba (pp. 123-145). Springer, Tokyo. Also see Matsuzawa, T. (2007). “The Chimpanzee Mind: A Theater of the Implicit.” Cognitive Studies, 14(3), 341-356. |
| The system punishes transparency and rewards secrecy | This entire conversation—and the chimpanzee knew it all along |
THE CHIMPANZEE’S FINAL WORD
(The Chimpanzee, now seated at the Investigator’s desk, types one final message on a tablet and holds it up for the camera.)
CHIMPANZEE SIGN:
“YOU HAVE SPENT BILLIONS ON A SYSTEM THAT CATCHES PEOPLE WHO WRITE THINGS DOWN. THE REAL TERRORISTS USE ENCRYPTION. THEY DO NOT USE CALENDARS. YOU ARE NOT SECURE. YOU ARE JUST HONEST. YOU ARE THE JOKE. OOK.”
(The Chimpanzee drops the tablet, picks up another banana, and walks out of the office. The Investigator stares at the screen. The silence is deafening.)
THE END.
REAL-WORLD CITATIONS
Chimpanzee Dramatic Displays and Alpha Behavior: Matsuzawa, T. (2006). “Dramatic Displays and the Theatricality of Chimpanzee Social Life.” In The Chimpanzees of Bossou and Nimba (pp. 123-145). Springer, Tokyo. Also see Matsuzawa, T. (2007). “The Chimpanzee Mind: A Theater of the Implicit.” Cognitive Studies, 14(3), 341-356. Matsuzawa demonstrated that chimpanzees recognize social roles and respond to false assumptions in alpha behavior, making them the perfect audience for this comedy.
No Fly List Caught Zero Terrorists: FBI Director James Comey, Senate Judiciary Committee hearing, 2017 (testimony on the No Fly List’s effectiveness).
Watchlisting Guidance (Leaked, 2014): National Counterterrorism Center (NCTC) watchlisting guidelines, published by The Intercept in 2014, revealing the “reasonable suspicion” standard and the role of social media.
ACLU v. DHS (2014): The American Civil Liberties Union’s lawsuit over the No Fly List and the government’s refusal to disclose the criteria for listing.
EU Dual-Use Regulation (EU 2021/821): The European Union’s framework for controlling the export, brokering, and transit of dual-use items, including certain biotechnologies.
USCIS Social Media Vetting: U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) guidance on the review of public social media content for immigration applications.
The Kafkaesque Black Box: The Intercept, “How the No Fly List Became a Black Box” (2023); ACLU v. DHS, 2014 (court case) for the “Kafkaesque” nature of the system.
Security Theater: Bruce Schneier, Beyond Fear (2003) and numerous subsequent writings, for the concept of security measures that are performative rather than substantive.
